Abstract:
Information and Communication Technology (ICT) holds significant potential to transform adult education by expanding access, enabling flexible learning, and supporting diverse learner needs. Yet, despite global policy commitments to digital inclusion, ICT integration in adult education remains uneven, particularly in under-resourced contexts. In South Africa, where historical inequalities continue to shape educational access, Adult Basic Education and Training (ABET) Community Learning Centres (CLCs) serve as critical second-chance learning spaces for disadvantaged adults but remain peripheral to national digital transformation agendas. This study investigated ICT integration in teaching and learning at two CLCs located in the Eastern Cape, South Africa, examining the availability and accessibility of ICT tools, the nature and frequency of ICT use, educators' perceptions of pedagogical value, and the availability and relevance of ICT-related professional development.
The study employed a qualitative, interpretivist, multiple-case study design. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews with 10 purposively selected participants: 4 adult educators, 4 adult learners, and 2 centre managers. Supplementary document analysis was used to examine selected national and sector policy and strategy documents and to contextualise the interview findings. Thematic analysis was used to identify patterns, while Activity Theory and Diffusion of Innovation Theory provided complementary lenses for interpreting ICT integration as both a systemic and an adoption-related process.
The findings revealed a fundamental contradiction: basic ICT infrastructure existed in the selected CLCs, yet its availability did not translate into meaningful pedagogical integration. Access was uneven, favouring ICT-related learning areas, while non-ICT areas remained underserved. ICT use was predominantly administrative and preparatory, focusing on lesson preparation, printing, and administrative tasks rather than sustained classroom integration. Participants perceived ICT as valuable for learner engagement, visualisation and conceptual understanding; however, these perceived benefits were constrained by unreliable infrastructure, restricted access, inadequate pedagogical training and weak institutional support. The study developed three empirically grounded conceptual contributions: conditional presence, referring to ICT infrastructure that is physically present but pedagogically constrained by institutional rules or infrastructure failures; hidden privatisation, referring to the informal transfer of ICT costs from institutions to educators through reliance on personal devices and data; and the pedagogical-digital divide, referring to the gap between basic digital access and educators' capacity to use ICT meaningfully for teaching and learning. These concepts extend discussion of the digital divide by foregrounding the pedagogical and institutional conditions under which technology becomes educationally useful.
The study concludes that ICT integration in ABET is a systemic challenge that requires alignment among infrastructure, institutional rules, professional development, and educator support. It recommends a CET-specific ICT policy, equitable access frameworks, ongoing pedagogical training, dedicated maintenance budgets, and stronger accountability mechanisms, offering both empirical evidence from an under-researched context and a diagnostic framework for understanding ICT integration failures in under-resourced adult education settings.