Abstract:
While the use of animals in scientific studies has contributed to scientific and medical advancements, there is public apprehension about the inhumane treatment of animals used in scientific studies. This has resulted in an increased need for the ethical use of animals in research. Ghana currently lacks a comprehensive regulatory framework for animals’ use in scientific studies, resulting in inconsistent application of ethical governance systems and practices in research-producing organisations, which is likely to undermine the credibility of studies using animals in the country. This study’s purpose was to propose an animal research ethics governance framework for research-producing organisations by interpreting key stakeholders’ (researchers, Animal Research Ethics Committee (AREC) members and AREC administrators) experiences of existing animal research ethics governance systems and practices in Ghana. To achieve this goal, the study was carried out over two sequential but interrelated phases: the empirical phase and the conceptual framework development phase. An exploratory, embedded single-case study that employed a qualitative research approach framed within an interpretive research paradigm was employed to achieve the objectives of the first phase of the project. Findings from this first phase showed that institutional ARECs were the main animal research ethics governance systems established in the country. Also, the lack of national guidelines in Ghana has resulted in a high dependence on international ethical guidelines for the governance of scientific studies using animals. Furthermore, the ethical approval practices (prereview, review and post-review activities), as well as training and awareness creation by ARECs, were identified as existing animal research ethics governance practices for the ethical use of animals in scientific studies in research-producing organisations in Ghana. Findings from the first phase of the study informed the realisation of the second phase, where the practice-oriented theory of Dickoff et al. (1968) was employed to develop a culturally sensitive conceptual animal research ethics governance framework that incorporates virtue ethics and the indigenous Ghanaian perspectives on animals. The framework proposes the 6R principles (replacement, reduction, refinement, relationship, respect and righteousness) to promote the ethical use of animals in scientific studies in research-producing organisations in Ghana. The study recommends the validation and implementation of the proposed animal research ethics governance framework to ensure the ethical and sustainable use of animals in scientific studies in Ghana. SUMMARY
While the use of animals in scientific studies has contributed to scientific and medical advancements over the years, there is growing public apprehension about the inhumane treatment of animals when used for scientific studies. This has resulted in an increased need for the ethical use of research animals through the establishment of laws, guidelines and policies to govern their treatment. Ghana currently lacks a comprehensive regulatory framework for the use of animals in scientific studies, resulting in the inconsistent application of ethical governance systems and practices in various institutions, which is likely to undermine the credibility of scientific studies using animals conducted in the country. Little is known about the governance systems and practices established at national and institutional levels to ensure that animals are used ethically in the conduct of research in Ghana. Therefore, there is a need to understand the existing animal research ethics governance systems and practices in the country to propose a governance framework that will ensure animals are used ethically in scientific studies in Ghana. Consequently, this study’s purpose was to propose an animal research ethics governance framework for research-producing organisations by interpreting key stakeholders’ experiences of existing animal research ethics governance systems and practices to promote the ethical use of animals in scientific studies in Ghana.
To achieve the study’s overarching purpose, this research was carried out over two sequential but interrelated phases. The empirical phase (phase one) and the conceptual framework development phase (phase two). An exploratory, embedded single-case study that employed a qualitative research approach framed within an interpretive research paradigm was employed to achieve the objectives of the first phase of the project. The study was conducted in three research-producing organisations with existing Animal Research Ethics Committees (ARECs) in Ghana. The study used semi-structured interviews and naïve sketches to collect data from 13 purposively sampled researchers, AREC members and AREC administrators, also referred to as key stakeholders throughout the thesis. An interview guide was used to guide the discussions, and interviews were audio recorded. Audio-recorded interviews were transcribed and thematically analysed using an inductive approach. To ensure the trustworthiness of the findings, authenticity, confirmability, credibility, dependability, reflexivity and transferability measures were employed by the researcher. Findings from the first phase of the study informed the realisation of the second phase, where the researcher employed the practice-oriented theory of Dickoff et al. (1968) to develop a conceptual animal research ethics governance framework.
Key stakeholders understood the concept of ‘animal research ethics governance’ to mean the existence of rules, regulations and oversight bodies such as ARECs for the ethical use of animals in scientific studies. ARECs established at research-producing organisations were identified as the main animal research ethics governance system established in a deficient national governance system currently in Ghana. The lack of national standards and guidelines in the country has resulted in a high dependence on international ethical standards and guidelines for the governance of scientific studies using animals. The findings also showed that the animal research ethics governance practices for the ethical use of animals in scientific studies are primarily encapsulated in the ethical approval procedures and processes of ARECs, which include pre-application, application review and post-approval practices. Additionally, training and awareness creation on the ethics of using animals in scientific studies among researchers, staff and students of research-producing organisations, and the general public, were identified as animal research ethics governance practices. Findings from the empirical phase (phase one) of the study informed the realisation of the conceptual framework development phase (phase two), where the practice-oriented theory of Dickoff et al. (1968) was employed to develop a culturally sensitive conceptual animal research ethics governance framework that incorporates virtue ethics and the indigenous Ghanaian perspectives on animals. The study further proposes the 6R principles of replacement, reduction, refinement, relationship, respect and righteousness for the ethical use of animals in scientific studies in research-producing organisations in Ghana. These principles were central to the development of a conceptual animal research ethics governance framework for the ethical use of animals in scientific studies in Ghana.