| dc.description.abstract |
This dissertation examines the constitutional and ethical dimensions of end-of-life decision-making in South Africa, where the prohibition of euthanasia leaves many patients dying without dignity. The study interrogates whether the current framework adequately protects dignity (s 10), bodily integrity (s 12), and access to healthcare (s 27), while recognising that (s 36), the limitations clause tempers the scope of these rights through proportionality analysis.
The dissertation demonstrates that the euthanasia debate cannot be considered independent from the availability of palliative care, as meaningful end-of-life choices depend upon access to adequate pain relief, support, and dignified care. Palliative care, though recognised in the National Health Insurance Act 20 of 2023, remains unevenly implemented, constrained by poor infrastructure, limited resources, and systemic inequities. The inadequate integration of mental health needs within palliative care widens the gap, leaving vulnerable patients without adequate support. Healthcare practitioners, regulated by the HPCSA, face ethical burdens without legislative clarity, while caregivers outside formal regulation shoulder unrecognised responsibilities. The research evaluates, the extent to which South Africa’s constitutional and legal framework adequately protects autonomy and dignity at the end of life, and what lessons can be drawn from comparative jurisdictions. Canada’s Medical Assistance in Dying (MAiD) regime is examined both as a model and a cautionary tale, demonstrating how assisted dying can coexist with palliative care under safeguards, but also how over-expansion risks eroding protections. The findings reveal that South Africa’s framework inadequately realises constitutional rights at the end of life. The study recommends strengthening and comprehensively expanding palliative care, ensuring it is accessible to all and effectively incorporated into the National Health Act framework. Only within such a system can debates on euthanasia proceed responsibly, reconciling constitutional principles with equitable, compassionate end-of-life care. |
en_US |