Institutional Repository

Proof beyond reasonable doubt: a South African study

Show simple item record

dc.contributor.advisor Museka, Chengetai Pamela
dc.contributor.author Mtshali, Cindy Nomkosi
dc.contributor.author Mtshali, Cindy Nomkosi
dc.date.accessioned 2026-10-20T08:37:37Z
dc.date.available 2026-10-20T08:37:37Z
dc.date.issued 2025
dc.identifier.uri https://ir.unisa.ac.za/handle/10500/33183
dc.description.abstract This study explores the challenges and shortcomings in the interpretation and application of the phrase "beyond a reasonable doubt" in South African criminal law. The study will also examine the historical origins, evolution, and legal significance of this standard within the South African legal system. The phrase "beyond a reasonable doubt" is analysed in the context of the right to a fair trial, as enshrined in Section 35(3) of the Constitution and Section 174 of the Criminal Procedure Act, 51 of 1977. Given the severe consequences of criminal convictions, this burden of proof is crucial in protecting the rights of accused persons. However, the effectiveness of this standard is often undermined by the state’s inability to present credible, sufficient, and admissible evidence. The study uses two case studies, S v Shrien Dewani (the "honeymoon murder") and S v Najwa Petersen and Others (the contract killing of Taliep Petersen), to illustrate how similar factual circumstances can lead to divergent judicial outcomes. Through comparative analysis, the research interrogates inconsistencies in the presentation and evaluation of evidence and the broader implications for justice and fairness. The research concludes that the instruction to prove guilt "beyond a reasonable doubt" remains conceptually ambiguous and practically difficult to implement. It calls for clearer definitions, improved evidentiary procedures, and strengthened collaboration between the NPA and SAPS to ensure justice is served in line with constitutional values. en_US
dc.format.extent 1 online resource (ix, 87 leaves)
dc.language.iso en en_US
dc.subject Burden en_US
dc.subject Judgment en_US
dc.subject Fairness en_US
dc.subject Sufficient evidence en_US
dc.subject Beyond a reasonable doubt en_US
dc.subject.lcsh Burden of proof -- South Africa
dc.subject.lcsh Reasonable doubt -- South Africa
dc.subject.lcsh Criminal procedure -- South Africa
dc.subject.lcsh Fair trial -- South Africa
dc.subject.lcsh Evidence, Criminal -- South Africa
dc.subject.other UCTD
dc.title Proof beyond reasonable doubt: a South African study en_US
dc.type Thesis en_US
dc.description.department School of Law
dc.description.degree LL.M. (Criminal and Procedural Law)
dc.date.updated 2026-10-20T07:49:10Z


Files in this item

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

  • Unisa ETD [13659]
    Electronic versions of theses and dissertations submitted to Unisa since 2003

Show simple item record

Search UnisaIR


Browse

My Account

Statistics