Institutional Repository

An analysis of procedural human rights in sports dispute resolution frameworks in South Africa

Show simple item record

dc.contributor.advisor Nyane, Hoolo
dc.contributor.author Thekisho, Lucky Lempiditse
dc.date.accessioned 2026-10-19T13:42:03Z
dc.date.available 2026-10-19T13:42:03Z
dc.date.issued 2026-08
dc.identifier.uri https://ir.unisa.ac.za/handle/10500/33171
dc.description.abstract Sports dispute resolution frameworks often operate in parallel to mainstream legal systems, and the South African sports dispute resolution framework is no exception. The rationale for this approach is to uphold sports autonomy. However, this parallelism creates a tension between preserving sports autonomy and upholding constitutional human rights obligations, particularly procedural rights. This study examines this tension in South Africa. South Africa’s Bill of Rights establishes substantive and procedural standards that all institutions, including private sporting bodies, must respect. The research addresses a critical problem: sports dispute resolution frameworks in South Africa often lack the procedural human rights guarantees typically available in mainstream justice systems. The study’s primary objective is to investigate these frameworks’ compliance with the procedural human rights standards set out in the South African Constitution and international instruments, and to evaluate the adherence of various sporting codes to the right of access to the courts and the principles of natural justice. The study uses the traditional doctrinal legal research methodology. The findings reveal a pervasive pattern among major sporting bodies in South Africa – SASCOC, SAFA and the CSA – of systematically prioritising organisational autonomy over the protection of procedural rights. These organisations employ mechanisms that function as de facto ouster clauses, limiting judicial oversight, while their adjudicative bodies lack independence and impartiality. Procedural complexity and resource asymmetries create significant barriers to accessing fair dispute resolution, particularly for individual athletes and smaller organisations. The frameworks exhibit troubling transparency deficits, the inconsistent application of procedural safeguards, and problematic patterns of judicial deference that challenge effective constitutional oversight. To address these deficiencies, the study makes the following recommendations: developing a comprehensive legislative framework that establishes minimum procedural standards; establishing an independent sports ombudsman; creating a collaborative Sports Procedural Rights Charter; implementing structural reforms to enhance adjudicative independence; improving transparency through systematic publication requirements; addressing resource asymmetries; providing specialised judicial training; aligning with international best practices; and implementing obligatory institutionally funded mediation. These reforms would reconcile the legitimate need for specialised sports governance with non-negotiable procedural justice requirements, strengthening the credibility of sports regulatory systems and protecting fundamental rights in South Africa’s constitutional democracy. en_US
dc.format.extent 1 online resource (x, 227 leaves)
dc.language.iso en en_US
dc.subject access to justice en_US
dc.subject arbitration independence en_US
dc.subject sports dispute resolution en_US
dc.subject procedural human rights en_US
dc.subject constitutional compliance en_US
dc.subject sporting autonomy en_US
dc.subject natural justice en_US
dc.subject.lcsh Dispute resolution (Law) -- South Africa
dc.subject.lcsh Sports -- Law and legislation -- South Africa
dc.subject.other UCTD
dc.title An analysis of procedural human rights in sports dispute resolution frameworks in South Africa en_US
dc.title.alternative An analysis of procedural human rights aspects of the sports dispute resolution frameworks in South Africa en_US
dc.type Thesis en_US
dc.description.degree Doctor of Laws
dc.date.updated 2026-10-15T18:24:00Z


Files in this item

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

  • Unisa ETD [13659]
    Electronic versions of theses and dissertations submitted to Unisa since 2003

Show simple item record

Search UnisaIR


Browse

My Account

Statistics