Institutional Repository

A qualitative exploration of the lived experiences of paramedics and firefighters as emergency medical services personnel

Show simple item record

dc.contributor.advisor Papaikonomou, M.
dc.contributor.author Matabane-Monama, Pebetse Rahab Garlie
dc.date.accessioned 2026-10-15T18:35:03Z
dc.date.available 2026-10-15T18:35:03Z
dc.date.issued 2026-02
dc.identifier.uri https://ir.unisa.ac.za/handle/10500/33141
dc.description.abstract The research study provides an insight into the lived experiences of the EMS personnel (firefighters and paramedics). The study aims to explore the relationship between the traumatic symptoms and fatigue experienced at work, as well as suicidal ideation or attempts, among emergency medical services (EMS) personnel (or safekeepers). The impact the traumatic experiences have on their romantic and familial relationships and their coping mechanisms were also explored. This qualitative research study employed purposive sampling to select eight participants. The sample was obtained during the COVID-19 pandemic but the country was on alert level one, therefore the restriction put in place were observed. The socio-demographic information from the participants varied according to professions, gender, years of service and age. The five firefighters’ age ranged from 31-53years of age with 11-30years of working experience. Whilst the three paramedics were approximately 34-40 years of age, with 7-10 years of working experience. A semi-structured interview was conducted with the participants. Thematic analysis was used to analyse the findings from the interactions the researcher had with the participants. The eight participants believe that they were born to serve. The findings from this study suggest that EMS personnel risk their lives to save others. While they are vulnerable to robberies, attacks and physical injuries, they report a lack of adequate support from their management. Debriefing, for example, is not arranged for them following traumatic exposure. The employer is said to be more concerned about statistics and physical fitness than their psychological wellbeing. The lack of growth experienced by the participants is demoralising and they have become desensitised to the trauma they are exposed to daily. It was found that the safekeepers are not motivated to seek help and that they have insufficient knowledge about psychological services or the employee assistance programme (EAP) offered to them. Although they feel unappreciated by management, they expressed that the community members’ level of gratitude encourages them to do more. Their interaction has defined their realities; however, their work has also had an impact on their family system. They take home the trauma they have experienced, and this is seen through the hypervigilance they display when around their loved ones. Participants presented with psychological problems that they had normalised as part of their lives, or they loosely labelled them as fatigue or stress. Offering debriefing sessions for EMS personnel after traumatic incidents may assist in reducing their psychological distress. The debriefing may also assist them in being familiar with the services the EAP offers and increase access to psychological interventions. Future researchers are also encouraged to explore possibilities of installing body or dashboard cameras to assist the police officials in capturing criminals targeting the EMS personnel. Sixteen main themes were identified in the study: Sense of failure; Self-blame; Maladaptive coping mechanisms; Exposure to trauma; Psychological and psychosomatic symptoms; Withdrawal from family; Bringing the job home; Effect of trauma on work performance; Team members as the main source of support; Seeing their family in victims; Neglected mental health; Empathy versus sympathy/compassion; Motivation or attitude towards work; Job demand and stagnation; Safety; No knowledge of scope of EMS; Gender challenges. These themes are interlinked and are not mutually exclusive. The themes reflect the participants’ personal life stories. The EMS personnel are fixated on their trauma as the study revealed that they are unable to integrate their life experiences with their trauma. Their trauma manifests as physical symptoms, as they are avoidant in addressing it. Their duties interfere with their psychosocial functioning, leading them to eventually use maladaptive coping mechanisms such as alcohol consumption and illicit drugs, or even committing suicide. There is a lack of urgency in seeking psychological help, often because there are no visible physical symptoms. They consider their psychological problems as part of life, influenced by their social interactions and shared experiences. Since the EMS personnel spend more time with each other, their life stories are similar, indicating that their realities are socially constructed by their environment. Employers should ensure that the EMS personnel are psychologically fit before they are expected to perform certain duties. However, it became apparent that the main focus of the employers is on the physical fitness of the EMS personnel, as evident by the gyms provided in their departments. Several sub-themes under the “Mental health neglected” theme emerged, including the absence of professional debriefing following exposure to traumatic scenes, lack of available counselling support, ineffectiveness of EAPs, prioritisation of physical fitness over mental health, and underutilisation of available counsellors. Participants expressed scepticism and distrust towards existing support services such as EAPs. They indicated that even when these services are available, they are not communicated or utilised effectively. Recommendations for practical implementation include the encouragement of other researchers to conduct a quantitative study of a similar topic in order to analyse numerical data and generalise the finding to a wider population. Different themes may also emerge during further investigation of a different population. A qualitative study may also be conducted at a geographical area where the sample and community members are of high class and reside in areas with infrastructures that are not restrictive. It is further recommended that managers also form part of the study to assess their level of insight into the EMS personnel’s complaints. The outcome of this study is not a global or holistic representation of all EMS personnel. en_US
dc.format.extent 1 online resource (xv, 467 leaves)
dc.language.iso en en_US
dc.subject Firefighters en_US
dc.subject Trauma en_US
dc.subject Mental health en_US
dc.subject Coping mechanisms en_US
dc.subject Employee assistance programme (EAP) en_US
dc.subject Paramedics en_US
dc.subject Emergency medical services personnel en_US
dc.subject.lcsh Emergency medical personnel -- Psychological aspects
dc.subject.lcsh Post-traumatic stress disorder
dc.subject.lcsh Emergency medical services -- South Africa
dc.subject.other UCTD
dc.title A qualitative exploration of the lived experiences of paramedics and firefighters as emergency medical services personnel en_US
dc.type Thesis en_US
dc.description.department Psychology
dc.description.degree Ph.D. (PhD)
dc.date.updated 2026-10-15T18:27:19Z


Files in this item

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

  • Unisa ETD [13659]
    Electronic versions of theses and dissertations submitted to Unisa since 2003

Show simple item record

Search UnisaIR


Browse

My Account

Statistics